QUICK ANSWER
Ask your bookkeeping provider three questions: who performs the work, where that person sits, and who has access to your QuickBooks Online file and your bank feeds. A provider should answer all three in one sentence each. At Hill Bookkeeping & Consulting the work is done by a team of five, in-house, in the United States.
Why this question is worth asking at all
Plenty of providers subcontract part or all of the production work, sometimes to firms in other countries, sometimes to contractors a few towns over. That arrangement is not inherently a problem. Good work is done that way every day, and the alternative is often a solo operator with no cover when they are ill. The problem is narrower than the one people usually argue about.
The problem is a provider who will not tell you. If the answer to who touches my file is vague, you have no way to assess continuity when someone leaves, no way to know how many people hold access to your bank feeds, and no way to judge whether the person who finds something odd in your numbers has the standing to raise it with you. That is not a geography question. It is a disclosure question, and the answer tells you a great deal about the rest of the relationship.
The three questions
- Who performs the monthly work, by name or by role? Not who owns the firm. Who does the reconciliations.
- Where does that person sit, and are they an employee or a subcontractor? Either answer is fine. A refusal to answer is not.
- Who has access to our QuickBooks Online file, our bank feeds and our payroll system, and how is that access removed when someone leaves?
A provider who has thought about this answers in under a minute. A provider who has not will reframe the question as being about trust, which is a tell. You are not asking them to prove their integrity. You are asking for an org chart.
Where Hill Bookkeeping & Consulting stands
The work is done by our own team of five, in-house, in the United States. Nothing is subcontracted offshore. Your file is worked on by people who know your business, which matters less for the reconciliations and a great deal for the moment when something in the numbers does not look right and someone has to decide whether it is worth a phone call.
The accurate caveat is that a team of five is a small team. It means you will know who is doing your work and they will know your business. It also means we are selective about who we take on, because the capacity is real rather than theoretical, and a firm that says yes to everything in November is a firm that misses dates in February.
Frequently asked questions
Is offshore bookkeeping a bad idea?
Not inherently. Capable work is done that way. What matters is whether the provider tells you, whether access to your accounts is controlled and removable, and whether the person who notices something unusual in your numbers is able to raise it with you directly.
How many people will have access to my QuickBooks Online file?
At Hill Bookkeeping & Consulting, the people working on your engagement and nobody else. Access is granted by role and removed when it is no longer needed. Ask any provider to put their answer to this in writing.
What happens if the person who does my books leaves?
With a team of five and a published close schedule, the handover is to someone already familiar with the file and the dates do not move. Continuity is one of the practical arguments for not using a sole operator.
NEXT STEP
If you do not know who is doing your books, start by asking your current provider. If the answer is unclear, a 20-minute call will tell you what a clearer arrangement would look like.
Book a 20-minute discovery call: here